Publishers Are Getting Destroyed (And What It Means For Your Content Strategy)

Publishers Are Getting Destroyed (And What It Means For Your Content Strategy)

Publishers Are Getting Destroyed (And What It Means For Your Content Strategy)

Nov 19, 2025

Look, I need to talk about something that's not getting enough attention in the marketing world.

While everyone's freaking out about the latest AI model release, People Inc. just reported that their Google traffic dropped from 54% to 24% in six months. That's not a typo. They lost more than half their organic traffic.

Here's the thing: this isn't about one publisher having a bad quarter. This is about Google's AI Overviews fundamentally changing how content performs in search. And most marketing teams I talk to aren't adjusting their content strategies fast enough.

What's Actually Happening (That Other Newsletters Won't Tell You)

VentureBeat reported that Anthropic just hit a $7B revenue run rate, with Claude Code reaching $500M ARR in just two months (fastest product launch in AI history, according to their analysis). Meanwhile, The Information claims OpenAI is projecting $74B in losses before profitability.

But here's what matters for your marketing stack: these aren't just interesting business metrics. This is a fundamental shift in how content gets discovered and consumed.

When People Inc.'s traffic collapses by 50%+, that's not just their problem. That's a preview of what's coming for content-dependent marketing funnels.

The Part Nobody's Talking About: Your Attribution Model Just Broke

I've been thinking through this with my team at AI Advantage (we work with 400+ clients, mostly in manufacturing and logistics). Here's the challenge nobody's addressing:

If AI Overviews are answering queries without click-throughs, your entire content marketing attribution model stops working. You can't track conversions from traffic that never hits your site.

According to Upwork's recent study, AI agents working solo only complete 30% of tasks successfully. But pair them with humans? That jumps to 70% completion.

This tracks with what we're seeing in campaign management. Tools like Claude Code (which Anthropic says hit $500M ARR faster than any product in AI history) are incredibly powerful. But they don't replace the strategic thinking about funnel optimization and conversion tracking.

Reality Check: What This Means For Your Q1 Content Budget

Let me be direct about the implementation challenges:

First, if you're still planning content strategy around traditional SEO metrics, you're optimizing for yesterday's algorithm. People Inc.'s 50% traffic drop should be a wake-up call.

Second, the tools getting built right now (like Claude Code at $499/month for enterprise features) can automate content production. But there's a catch: according to Upwork's data, automation without human oversight has a 70% failure rate on complex tasks.

Third, and this is what most marketing teams miss: your content needs to be structured for AI consumption, not just human readers. That means schema markup, clear information hierarchy, and answering specific queries concisely. Most websites I audit aren't even close to ready for this.

What You Should Actually Do (Based On Real Implementation Experience)

If you're planning content strategy for 2025, here's what we're testing with our clients (we've allocated up to $10K per client to validate these approaches):

Shift attribution models: Stop measuring only traffic and start tracking brand mention in AI responses. We're experimenting with tools that monitor how often client brands appear in Claude, ChatGPT, and Perplexity responses.

Create AI-optimized content formats: According to the People Inc. case, the content that survives needs to provide unique value beyond what AI can summarize. Think data sets, original research, interactive tools.

Pair automation with human oversight: That Upwork study showing 70% completion rates with human+AI isn't surprising. We're seeing similar patterns. Use Claude Code or similar tools for draft generation, but have experienced marketers optimize for conversion.

Test new traffic sources: If Google's AI Overviews are eating your organic traffic, where else can you drive qualified visitors? We're experimenting with AI-powered research tools, partner networks, and direct integrations with AI assistants.

Fair warning: this transition period is messy. Most marketing automation platforms weren't built for a world where 50% of your organic traffic disappears in six months. Integration challenges are real.

The Uncomfortable Truth About 2025

While Matt Wolfe predicts that AI agents will be the dominant trend in 2025, and The Rundown covered Jeff Bezos raising $6.2B for Project Prometheus, most marketers are still optimizing for the old playbook.

Here's what I'm seeing from my network of founders and teams who've deployed these tools at scale: the winners are the ones who accepted that content marketing fundamentally changed, not the ones hoping it'll go back to normal.

Anthropic's path to profitability by 2028 while OpenAI projects $74B in losses tells you everything about sustainable business models in AI. The same applies to marketing: sustainable strategies adapt to reality, not hype.

Tomorrow I'll break down the specific schema markup changes that could protect your content from AI Overview cannibalization. Hit reply if you want early access to the framework we're testing.

Looking for a community of like-minded individuals who are interested in AI and Entrepreneurship? Join our free community here to get started:The AI Advantage Community. Thank you for reading! -Shawn.

Subscribe To Out Newsletter

Subscribe To Out Newsletter

Subscribe To Out Newsletter

Subscribe To Out Newsletter

Subscribe To Out Newsletter

Share It On: